What payment methods can I use for Autoship? September 11, 2019 02:02 Autoship orders are processed via credit card or PayPal only. Afterpay and Zippay are not available on Autoship orders. Related articles How do I manage my Autoship details? How will I know when my Autoship order has been sent? How much notice do you need to cancel or postpone my Autoship? Do I need to be a member to create an Autoship? Can I cancel my Autoship?