What payment methods can I use for Autoship? January 04, 2022 20:32 Updated Autoship orders are processed via credit card only. PayPal, Afterpay, and Zippay are not available on Autoship orders. Related articles Can I earn PETstock Rewards on my Autoship? What is Autoship? What payment methods do you offer? I've got a few items in my cart, but I only want one product on my Autoship order. Can I do this? I received an email that said my Autoship order has failed, why?